Books like Icebreaker

Looking for more books like Icebreaker by Hannah Grace? You're not alone! Since this charming sports romance skated onto bookshelves, readers have been desperately seeking that same perfect blend of witty banter, slow-burn chemistry, and heartwarming moments. Whether you fell for the enemies-to-lovers ice hockey setting or Nathan and Anastasia's sizzling chemistry, I've got you covered with these irresistible books similar to Icebreaker that will give you all the same warm and fuzzy feelings. Just a heads-up, this post contains affiliate links, meaning we may earn a small commission (at no extra cost to you!)

Books Similar to Icebreaker

Book Cover

The Bride Test

Helen Hoang

The Bride Test delivers that same heart-fluttering feeling as Icebreaker with its beautifully awkward characters navigating unexpected attraction. Like Nathan's struggle to express his feelings, Khai's neurodivergent perspective creates delicious tension as Esme patiently breaks through his walls. The slow-burn romance unfolds with the same genuine emotional depth that made you fall for Anastasia and Nathan, while exploring cultural differences and personal growth. If you loved how Icebreaker balanced humor with tender vulnerable moments, Hoang's thoughtful romance offers that same satisfying emotional journey with characters you'll be rooting for from page one.

Buy on Bookshop

How it's similar to Icebreaker

Subgenre

Romance

Tone

Emotional/Heartwarming
Humorous

Narrative

Character-Driven
Dialogue-Heavy
Lyrical/Descriptive
Multi-Perspective
Plot-Driven

Character Tropes

The Hero
The Lover
The Mentor
The Outsider
The Rebel

Plot Tropes

Enemies to Lovers
Love
Sacrifice
The Hero's Journey
The Journey

Setting Tropes

Conflict Tropes

Dysfunctional Families
Identity Crisis
Man vs. Self

Theme Tropes

Coming of Age
Friendship
Grief and Loss
Search for Meaning
Book Cover

Yours Truly

Abby Jimenez

Fans of the witty workplace tension in Icebreaker will devour Yours Truly, where Dr. Briana Ortiz and Dr. Jacob Maddox clash in a hospital setting instead of an ice rink. Just like Anastasia and Nathan's competitive dynamic, Briana and Jacob's initial hostility masks a simmering attraction that develops through thoughtful gestures and surprising moments of vulnerability. The novel features the same perfect balance of laugh-out-loud humor and emotional depth that made Icebreaker so impossible to put down. With swoony banter, deeply relatable characters working through personal challenges, and that irresistible enemies-to-lovers chemistry, this romance hits all the same sweet spots.

Buy on Bookshop

How it's similar to Icebreaker

Subgenre

Romance

Tone

Emotional/Heartwarming
Humorous

Narrative

Character-Driven
Dialogue-Heavy
Lyrical/Descriptive
Multi-Perspective
Plot-Driven

Character Tropes

The Hero
The Lover
The Outsider
The Rebel

Plot Tropes

Enemies to Lovers
Love
Sacrifice
The Hero's Journey
The Journey

Setting Tropes

Small Town

Conflict Tropes

Dysfunctional Families
Identity Crisis
Man vs. Self

Theme Tropes

Coming of Age
Friendship
Grief and Loss
Search for Meaning
Book Cover

Life's Too Short

Abby Jimenez

Another heartwarming novel by author Abby Jimenez, Life's Too Short captures the same charming neighborhood vibes and found family warmth that made Icebreaker so cozy and inviting. Like Nathan's unexpected involvement in Anastasia's world, attorney Adrian Copeland finds himself suddenly entangled in his vibrant neighbor Vanessa's complicated life. The slow-building relationship evolves from reluctant proximity to genuine connection, mirroring the delightful tension between our hockey rivals. What really makes this book similar to Icebreaker is how it balances lighthearted moments with deeper themes, both feature characters who learn to open themselves to love despite significant personal obstacles, all wrapped in Jimenez's signature humor that will leave you highlighting passages to read again.

Buy on Bookshop

How it's similar to Icebreaker

Subgenre

Romance

Tone

Emotional/Heartwarming
Humorous

Narrative

Character-Driven
Dialogue-Heavy
Lyrical/Descriptive
Multi-Perspective
Plot-Driven

Character Tropes

The Hero
The Lover
The Outsider
The Rebel

Plot Tropes

Love
Sacrifice
The Hero's Journey
The Journey

Setting Tropes

Small Town

Conflict Tropes

Dysfunctional Families
Identity Crisis
Man vs. Self

Theme Tropes

Coming of Age
Friendship
Grief and Loss
Search for Meaning
Book Cover

The Fiance Dilemma

Elena Armas

If you fell in love with the emotional and heartwarming romance of Icebreaker, then The Fiancé Dilemma by Elena Armas is another must-read. This novel follows a heated enemies-to-lovers dynamic between a fiercely independent Josie and the man she never expected to fake an engagement with. When circumstances force them to pretend to be the perfect couple, despite their undeniable friction, sparks fly, leading to a slow-burning romance filled with banter, tension, and unexpected vulnerability. If you love swoon-worthy romance with depth, The Fiancé Dilemma will steal your heart.

Buy on Bookshop Buy on Libro.fm

How it's similar to Icebreaker

Subgenre

Romance

Tone

Emotional/Heartwarming
Humorous

Narrative

Character-Driven
Dialogue-Heavy
Lyrical/Descriptive
Multi-Perspective
Plot-Driven

Character Tropes

The Hero
The Lover
The Outsider
The Rebel

Plot Tropes

Enemies to Lovers
Love
The Hero's Journey
The Journey

Setting Tropes

Conflict Tropes

Dysfunctional Families
Identity Crisis
Man vs. Self

Theme Tropes

Coming of Age
Friendship
Search for Meaning